Putnam 2001 A4
- Session A
Triangle has an area 1. Points lie, respectively, on sides , , such that bisects at point , bisects at point , and bisects at point . Find the area of the triangle .
Curated text Kedlaya Putnam archive. Quoted with source.
Solutions
Human solution Solution 1 by Misha Lavrov
First, look at just one pair of lines with one condition: is a point on line , and bisects at point .
If and , we can find a relationship between and . For example, using areas: since bisects , . We have , and so , which is easiest to write as .
The actual algebraic relationship is not super important to this step, but I derive it to give a rigorous proof of an intuitive fact: as increases, decreases, and vice versa.
The same relationship must hold between any two of the three ratios, by an identical proof.
Now suppose that (for a fixed equilateral ) there are multiple possible ways to draw that satisfy the condition. Choose one with the maximum possible value of . Then it must have the minimum possible value of . Then it must have the maximum possible value of , from which we deduce that actually it has the minimum possible value of . In other words, only one value of , and similarly only one value of and , is possible.
Having shown uniqueness, we are finally ready to look at what happens when we apply the rotation that takes to , to , and to . In general, this takes the points to points such that segments , , and satisfy the condition in the problem; in other words, , , and have the property we want. But because the solution is unique, we must have , , and . From this, in the equilateral case follows.
Mathematics Stack Exchange. Open licence.
Human solution Solution 2 by Manjul Bhargava, Kiran Kedlaya and Lenny Ng
The terms of the source let olymmath link to this solution but not copy it. Read the solution (Kedlaya Putnam archive).
Similar problems
These problems have the most words in common with this statement.